For most of 2026, the Village of Oak Creek was the tighter of the Sedona area's two housing markets. This fall the two ZIP codes swapped places. The City of Sedona, 86336, ended September at 5.30 months of supply. The Village, 86351, reached 7.13 months in October, and by the usual six-month benchmark that puts it in buyer's market territory. Those figures come from a fall market column in Sedona Red Rock News.
The same column reported that the Village's average sale price fell 34 percent from the prior period, to $869,000, in that October snapshot. Buyers who saw that drop on a portal may have taken it as a discount. The supply figure is the better guide to the Village right now. The price figure comes from too few sales to carry much meaning.
Fifteen Sales Cannot Carry an Average
The October Village average came from 15 transactions. In a month that small, the average depends on which homes closed. Two or three sales at the top of the Village's range can lift it, and a month without them pulls it down, even when no individual home lost value. The Red Rock News column says as much, noting that "a few higher-end sales can swing a 15-transaction month significantly."
Two other October figures say more. The Village's sale-to-list ratio rose to 99.0 percent, so homes that did sell went for nearly their asking price. Months of supply crossed the six-month line. Together they describe a market where buyers have more listings to choose from and still pay close to asking for the right house. The column also put the shift in context: Village sales had run 83 percent above the prior year during a busy summer, and October's inventory came after that run.
For a buyer, the practical effect is time. With more than seven months of supply, a buyer can compare homes and doesn't have to act on the first one that fits. But a 99 percent sale-to-list ratio means an opening offer far below a well-priced home's asking price has little support in the recent sales.
What Sits Behind the City's Tighter Number
On the Sedona side, the September numbers point the other way. The City's average sale price recovered to $1.30 million that month, from $1.16 million in July and August. Supply fell from 6.79 months to 5.30, and sale-to-list held at 96.7 percent. Year to date through September, the 86336 average was running at $1.32 million, and the September price per square foot was $539. The column called the summer dip and fall recovery a normal Sedona seasonal pattern, after a May and June peak near $1.58 million.
Sales volume in the City was down 13 percent from the year before. A falling sales count alongside tighter supply means fewer homes are coming to market, and that tells a buyer more than a rising price does.
Part of the City's buyer pool is also shopping for something different. Of the 27 single-family closings across Sedona and the Village in August 2026, three were established Airbnb properties with documented rental histories. The median sale price that month was $1,212,500, and the median listing took 62 days to sell. The City of Sedona's own figures show how much of its housing serves that market. Community Development Director Tony Allender told Sedona Red Rock News in April that short-term rentals had grown from 454 single-family units in 2020 to 1,041. At that count they made up 18.1 percent of the city's housing stock, compared with 17.6 percent for long-term rentals. In March, Deputy City Manager Lauren Browne told KNAU that nearly a quarter of Sedona homes were short-term rentals, and she described blocks where seven homes in a row had been converted.
The City is working on the other side of that balance. Its draft Balanced Housing Strategy, presented in September, aims for 775 units over 10 years, backed by $19 million in the city's housing fund, according to Sedona Red Rock News. On Oct. 13, council directed staff to move forward on two city-owned sites and to develop a land-trust partnership and possible down-payment assistance of up to $150,000 per buyer, the paper reported. These are City of Sedona programs, and they shape the 86336 market. The Village sits in unincorporated Yavapai County, so it has a different set of local institutions.
The Village's Running Costs Are Set Outside City Hall
In the Village, the community-level news this fall came from a water company, a fiber builder and the county, and it reached residents through the Big Park Regional Coordinating Council.
Big Park Water and Little Park Water ran consolidated rate and merger cases before the Arizona Corporation Commission. The ACC docket records Decision No. 81614, dated Jan. 20, 2026. At the council's Oct. 8, 2026 meeting, Big Park Water's manager said the new rates took effect and Little Park merged into Big Park in February. He described the increase as 21.67 percent, or about $8 a month, taking a typical bill from about $38 to $46. He also reported $4.3 million in system improvements, including expanded storage and pumping capacity, backup power and 3,300 digital meters. Those figures are the utility's typical-bill example, offered as general information. Buyers should confirm what a specific property's bill will be with the provider and their own advisors.
The council's September summary noted that Wecom Fiber was building a new underground broadband network in the Village of Oak Creek. For a buyer planning to work remotely from a Village home, that buildout is worth tracking alongside the inventory count.
The Old School Campus Is the Village's Largest Pending Project
The largest pending decision in the Village is the former Big Park Community School campus. In March, Sedona Red Rock News reported that the Sedona-Oak Creek School District board accepted a $10 million bid for the campus. A competing bid from Toll Brothers had proposed about 40 homes for $6.65 million. On Sept. 16, the board voted 5-0 to extend the closing date a third time, the paper reported.
The buyer's stated plan is to keep the library and other tenants and to turn the gym and adjacent rooms into a community center, which would need county funding and operation. Yavapai County Supervisor Nikki Check said the county had met with the buyers and had identified the property as a project in its budget retreat and rural-services study. At the Big Park council's Oct. 8 meeting, the sale was reported as not yet complete. The two bids proposed very different futures for the site, and buyers looking at homes near the campus should get the latest status before they make an offer.
Near Bell Rock, Yavapai County supervisors approved a proposed event lawn at Hilton Sedona Resort at Bell Rock in late 2025, Sedona Red Rock News reported.
A Few Direct Questions
Did Village of Oak Creek home values fall 34 percent? No sale-by-sale evidence shows that. The 34 percent figure is a change in the average across 15 October closings, and the mix of homes that closed accounts for part of it. The 99.0 percent sale-to-list ratio that same month shows sellers getting close to their asking prices.
Which ZIP gives a buyer more room to negotiate right now? By supply, the Village does: 7.13 months in October against 5.30 in the City in September. Room to negotiate shows up as more choice and more time to decide. Recent sale-to-list ratios in both ZIPs do not support steep discounts on well-priced homes.
If you are weighing a home along SR-179 in the Village of Oak Creek against one in 86336, The Red Rock Collective would be glad to talk through the recent sales around that specific property with you before you set a number. Let's Connect.